2013-01-22

Electronic city signs a driving distraction

In my city they recently installed some orange text signs over some of the major roads, and I've seen similar ones over the freeways. I was looking at what they show on them and surprised at how useless, irrelevant, and distracting it was. Mostly I've just seen them showing the time and date. One I saw flashing several screens, describing some road closure many days in the future. And on another I saw flashing several screens describing how one should not drink a drive, presumably because it makes one unable to give adequate attention to driving.

Now, consider the context of these. People are driving down the road, hopefully trying to pay attention to driving and any dangers that come up. They see these signs above the road, likely flashing information at them. Naturally a driver will assume that the information is important for them to read, like those temporary signs put up in front of road construction instructing the driver what to do next. But these signs aren't flashing anything relevant for the driver.

Every car made in the last several decades has a clock on the dashboard. Information about road closures days in the future is a distraction to most drivers. And several screens of information about drunk driving, presented to people on the freeway, is a pure distraction from driving. It's ironic given that the apparent purpose is to make driving safer, and especially so in the context of all the recent focus on texting while driving. Anything attempting to draw a driver's attention should be doing so only if it's immediately relevant in the next stretch of road. Period.

What, then, should these signs be showing? Most of the time, nothing! Keep them blank most of the time. If there's some immediately useful information, like a wreck, lane closures, detours, put it up. If possible, keep it a single screen so it's not flashing and drawing attention. That's it. Save the information about other days for the city's traffic website. Save the driving education for billboards or the web. Since the signs will be blank most of the time, their showing information will be exceptional and will be noticed. Don't fill them with unimportant information just because you have nothing important to put there.

No comments: